A few months ago I read “Banker to the poor” by Muhammad Yunus. Yunus is famous for the microcredit system in the modern world, with the purpose of lending money to the poor at low-interest rates. In his book, Yunus explains the whole process of how Grameen Bank was born and how he got the idea of lending money to the poor, and all the struggles it involved with the Bangladesh government’s bureaucracy. Personally, I really liked the idea, because he created a whole new system that helped poor people to be more independent by starting their own small businesses, pension funds, and even a private health care system, at very low-interest rates. Yunus mentions that governments are not very good at helping the poor and that this type of systems where the lenders own the community bank that offers different private services, is more helpful in the long run to get them out of poverty and to activate the local economy.
Similar banks were inspired by Yunus’ idea around the world, but not all of them followed the same path. Compartamos is one of them, a Mexican microlending institution founded in 1990 as an NGO. In 2000 it changed its path and it was transformed into a *Sofol (Sociedad Financiera de Objeto Limitado), and in 2007 it held its IPO in the Mexican Stock Exchange. What? A micro-credit institution listed on a stock exchange? Yes, Yunus had the same reaction, and he even criticized this institution by saying that “Microcredit was created to fight the money lender, not to become the money lender”. Grameen charges an interest rate of 20% and 10% go back to its operations(bloomberg.com), while Compartamos charged an average 71% in 2013 (expansion.mx). Big difference right?, but they are also different type of businesses.
I am sure that Compartamos has helped many families, and single mothers as they claim, but it would have been more beneficial for the borrowers if it would have remained as an NGO or as another organization that would have permitted a community banking system, like Grameen. Today, Compartamos’ mission might be to help people to get out of poverty, but they also need to be profitable for their investors. They are in their right to do it, and I think that they are a social responsible business with a positive impact in society, but I agree with Yunus that “when you discuss microcredit, don’t bring Compartamos into it”.
*A Sofol is basically a financial institution that can only lend to the public, but cannot receive deposits.
Sources:
Click to access infoanua_687825_2015_1.pdf
http://expansion.mx/especiales/2013/02/15/los-directores-que-comparten-el-poder
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2007-12-12/online-extra-yunus-blasts-compartamos